Category Archives: Uncategorized
Reframing Hope (A Book Review)
I read Reframing Hope: Vital Ministry in a New Generation by Carol Howard Merritt for a recent continuing education event. I struggled with the book, initially, for two reasons. When I started, I felt like this was one of those books that helpfully tells pastors everything about church is changing and that’s it. No help for how to cope with change, how to educate around and love into change. The other reason I felt frustrated was that I was holding a book in my hands about ministry to 20-30 somethings (or so it seemed). If I could get them to meet me somewhere, anywhere, I’d be glad to try new ministries with them, but…
So I dragged my feet about reading the book until on the plane flight for the event. Once I started to read, I felt drawn in to Merritt’s style and narrative. She actually has been a pastor of a small congregation and is now in a larger context. I resist reading books where I feel like the person is talking at me and Merritt’s voice is the exact opposite. She speaks from her own pastoral knowledge and spiritual longing. She explores the topics of social media, Scriptural understanding, relationship to creation and community activism, describing new ways that congregations are coming to understand themselves through these lenses.
I remember a woman in a preaching class I took telling one of those apocryphal stories about a “new preacher”. Said preacher was going to do his first sermon in a new congregation. Nervous, he studied the passages and did his own translation from the ancient languages. He read multiple commentaries and authored several versions of the sermon. He had illustrations, sung refrains, voice modulation and a powerful conclusion. When he delivered the sermon, he worked up a sweat and prayed powerfully at the end. When he was greeting members of the church at the end of the service, one of the matriarchs of the church said to the young pastor, “You’ve got powerful living water, but you have to bring it to us in a cup we can drink from.”
I thought of that anecdote several times while reading Reframing Hope. Merritt brings difficult news, but refreshing grace in a cup from which any congregation can drink.
Mainline churches are slowly coming to grips with the reality that people aren’t seeking spiritual services in the same way they once were. However, this doesn’t mean change for the sake of change. It means rethinking the roots of a church’s faith. What’s important to your congregation? Is there a way to offer those core values to one another and a neighborhood that might look different? Is it time to consider offering the new covenant in a different cup, so to speak?
Too often churches look at what people are drawn to outside of church and then try to imitate that. As Merritt points out, the imitation is poor and not flattering to either side. In addition, the implication is then that the church has nothing to offer of its own accord. No wonder people don’t see the point, if what the church holds out is a strained pablum of entertainment and self-justification.
Merritt writes:
It is easy for our churches and denominations to slip into a narrative of decline, which leads us to impart a message of deprivation: Come to our church because we need more people, money, and energy (which doesn’t sound like good news at all). If we want to reach out to a new generation, we must avoid communicating that we’re seeking just another warm body in the pew, another giving unity to meet the budget, or more volunteers for our programs.
Yet, if our churches can develop and communicate a narrative that invites people to enter- if they are places where a person can slip into the pew for an hour of internal wrestling, where she can mentally question everything that happens, and at the end of it, she knows that such a questioning is okay- then people will attend again. Because, after all, we often talk about the spiritual journey as a matter of acceptance, but in reality it has more to do with struggle. Then, after a good long time, if she’s willing to listen to the stories of the community, her own story will begin to form in her belly. It’s an extensive, tough and beautiful process. And it is only of the great things about being church.
I think that’s the heart of reframing hope and drinking from a new cup. In our pews, social halls, Facebook groups, Twitter feeds and late night conversations, we have to be honest about our questions, our doubts and our certainties. There are people who are thirsty and our Mainline congregations (among others) know where to find Living Water. We must learn to reorient ourselves to the new tools of communication and meetings, while holding fast to what is true.
The way, the truth and the life is not in our denominational polity, our traditional Easter service, a new afterschool drop-in program or a sports complex. It is Jesus Christ and how he meets us in one another in every day encounters. By rethinking how we encounter people in preaching, worship, Bible study, recreation and environmental stewardship, we take our hope and place it, once again, squarely in God’s hands.
I keep thinking of Paul’s words to the embroiled Corinthians: In the end, three things will last: faith, hope and love. And the greatest of these is love. (The Word According Julia interpretation)
The greatest of these is love. Faith without love is dogmatism. Hope without love is bleak. But love without faith or hope longs for structure and impetus.
Merritt’s love for the Church as God’s work on earth shines through her analysis and prodding. Her faith in our ability as church people to make change is perhaps deeper than we deserve. Her hope, though, that people will understand that the world thirsts and we can help, if we’ll just look at the cup we’re using. Think of Indiana Jones. What kind of a cup would a carpenter use? While the world changes at a rapid pace, the Church has the opportunity to provide respite and the consolation of mystery if we’re willing to reframe our objectives and our understanding of what it means to be a congregation, united in hope and love.
I recommend Merritt’s book to people who are trying to understand the changing dynamics of the Mainlines and emergent traditions. I have an extra copy of this book, purchased with my own money, to give away. Please comment if you’d like to receive it. If I receive more than one request, I’ll choose a recipient at random.
Songs in a Slow Season, or Why I Love Lenten Hymns
I received a message today from a source who shall remain nameless asking, “Why are there no good Lenten hymns?”
Aside from the fact that I was greatly anticipating singing Fanny Crosby’s “Jesus, Keep Me Near the Cross”, I also took umbrage on behalf of Lenten hymns in general. Greatly maligned in moderns times, I often hear, “It’s better than what we sing in Lent,” with regard to some hymn that has yet to reach popular heights.
I like the Lenten hymns and their deeply resonant lyrics. What else reaches the lyrical heights of “In the Cross of Christ I Glory”: “When the woes of life o’er take me, hopes deceive and fears annoy, never shall the cross forsake me; lo, it glows with peace and joy.”? Can you honestly say you feel nothing when you sing, “I Want Jesus to Walk With Me”?
I realized today that I think I prefer the Lenten hymns to the Advent ones. In Advent, we sing about a hope that is still to be fulfilled, the return of Christ, even as we celebrate with joy the first coming of Jesus. In Lent, though, we sing of our struggles with faith, with sacrifice, with grief and loss.
If you don’t like singing, that’s a different issue. However, I’m a little bit of a hymn fanatic. My life flows on in endless song and I hold to the faith we sing. For me, the Lenten hymns express the depth of that faith in a way that is unique and special.
I may have to use this season to showcase a few of my favorite Lenten hymns. (If I knew how to make a bracket, I’d take nominations and we could have a little tournament.)
First up, “Come, Ye Disconsolate”. This is my number 1 seed Lenten song (and one of my 4 funeral selections).
The lyrics are below and I’ve included two VERY different arrangements of the song for your listening enjoyment.
Blowing in the Wind (Sermon 3/20)
Friday Five: Spring Forward Edition
Friday Five: Springing Forward
Jan writes: Whether we liked it or not, we all “sprang forward” with the change to daylight savings time in the USA this past Sunday. There is lightness and brightness slipping in as spring approaches, so let us consider what is springing forth in our lives right now.
Name 5 things that are springing forth, possibly including :
- what you hope for
- what you dread
- what you observe
- what is concrete
- what is intangible
Theodicy, the Odyssey
Theodicy is the fancy name for those late-night, exhaustion or substance-fueled, discussions wherein one tries to balance the goodness of God (or the presumed goodness of God) with the existence of evil. The same name is also applied to the philosophical or theological study of the same. I know no one who hasn’t had this discussion, so I hardly think formal rules apply.
In the wake of the 8.9 magnitude earthquake in Japan, many people are having this conversation. Even as we pray, “Lord, in your mercy remember your creation”, we wonder how this can happen. I know some of my brothers and sisters in faith, even now, are sorting through the history of Japanese sins, but many others are already collecting or sending funds, supplies and heartfelt prayers.
Does God cause these things to happen? Answering this question would take me into the realm of apologetics, the theological field of explanation. I’m neither qualified nor able to be God’s apologist.
Here’s why: Consider Isaiah 45:6-7
I realize I’m proof-texting from two verses what I could easily undermine by discussing God’s love for creation, promise to Noah and even other verses in Isaiah. However, the end result will be the same. I don’t know why bad things happen. I believe God is in control, but I also believe that God does not subvert the way that nature plays out.
The Lutheran theologian Martin Marty says this:
God the creator creates out of love. That creation finds us in a created and hence “natural” world, not Eden of old or Paradise of tomorrow or Utopia in between. Since we belong to the created or natural world, we are subject to all that goes with it, including birth and death, springtime and autumn, sunshine and shadow- some lives knowing outrageously more of the latter than of the former. And as we belong to created nature, we also live in a world in which accidents happen, unexplained good and bad things occur. Those people killed by the fallen tower of Siloam just happened to be there, and the surviving soldier whom one bullet missed just happened to have moves before it came and killed his buddy behind him. (Marty, Martin E. Lutheran Questions, Lutheran Answers. Augsburg Fortress, Minneaoplis, MN. 2007. p. 45)
What Marty is saying is that we don’t always know why things happen, but we’re not called to stark realism, we’re called to hopefulness in the presence of God in suffering and in joy. We may never fully understand the whys and wherefores in this life, but we simply focus on the the gift of life we have and on trying not to cause more chaos than already happens around us.
For today, Psalm 46 in haiku:
God is our refuge,
a timely help in trouble,
the Giver of strength.
Never shall we fear
even though mountains should fall
into ocean depths;
when wild waters rage
and mountain are washed by waves,
God is our stronghold.
Consider God’s works
and the redoubtable deeds
He has done on earth:
He has stamped out wars,
breaking bows and snapping spears
setting shields ablaze.
‘Know that I am God,
supreme among the nations,
high above the earth!”
Yahweh Sabaoth,
the Lord of hosts, is with us.
Jacob’s God, our shield.
Gwyn, Richard. The Psalms in Haiku Form. Gracewing, Fowler Wright Books, Herefordshire; 1997. p. 52
Collar Me Purple
So, I’ve taken on the Lenten discipline of wearing my clerical collar. I’ve debated this before and I did promise a parishioner that I would wear it for a week, if he wore the pectoral cross for a week. He did, mostly, so I will, mostly.
I’ve even taken to wearing an Anglican collar, so I can’t just slip the tab out. I’ll be wearing during my working hours until I go home, but not on my days off (unless I go to a work function).
I’ve resisted the collar previously for the following reasons: 1) Actual physical discomfort. Both the tab and the full circle are close fitting around the neck. In addition to feeling a little tight, it makes me hot. I hate being hot. The Anglican collar has an additional, hair-shirt quality that comes from the collar stud that pokes into the middle of my throat.
2) In cognito. It’s much easier to go in and out of the grocery store, car dealership, Sears, gas station without people asking questions or staring. And it does happen.
3) Alaska casual. I have seen clergy, mainly men, wearing their clericals daily, but I can name 2. Some clergy I know wear the shirts, but keep the collar optional, putting it on as needed (such as to go into the hospital). This isn’t a suit-state. I’m a fairly casual person, particularly in dressing, but the collar seems to call for a little something more.
4) Along with being “undercover”, not wearing a collar keeps me from spontaneous confessor status. Once people “know” you’re clergy, they have a range of things to confess from unbelief, to struggles with the church, to divorce and all manner of faith struggles.
On the other hand, it’s arguable that wearing the collar creates ministry opportunities that I’m missing right now. Wearing a dickey allows me to still be fairly casual. And if I lost more weight, maybe the collars wouldn’t be as snug.
In reality, I think wearing my collar more frequently will help me to consider aspects of this call and vocation that I usually ignore or that I have yet to consider.
Already, last night, I stopped on the way home to buy a few groceries. When I came to the check-out line, both the checker and the customer stared at me. I just unloaded my cart and then the customer, a woman, asked, “Are you, um, clergy?”
“Yes,” I said, wondering what would happen next.
“Have you seen that show… um…” she began, pausing.
“Oh, you mean, ‘What Not to Wear’?” I guessed she might be referring the TLC show, which featured an Episcopalian clergy woman a few months ago. Her congregation wanted to spruce up her wardrobe and, among other things, she got a very nice, custom-made clergy dickie.
“Yes, that show,” she said. “I loved that show and they gave her one of those things you’re wearing.”
“I went to school with the woman on the show,” I said, which I did. “They did make a collar for her, but it’s about $90 and this one is $25.”
“Wow, there’s a big difference then.” she said.
As I nodded, she moved her cart away and the checker began processing my few groceries. “I love that show,” the checker said.
I nodded, noncommittally, since I don’t have television and have never seen the show.
I could see the other customer waiting, just beyond the registers.
As I began to push my cart toward the parking lot, she fell into step next to me.
“You don’t look so fuddy-duddy, though,” she confided. (I assume she dropped the “for a pastor”.)
“Thanks,” I said. “I’m not much for suits, so it’s good to live here.”
We both laughed and went on our way.
And now at least two women have encountered a woman clergy person, in real life, wearing regular clothes and the “uniform” of her calling and she was a real person.
I think I have a lot to learn in the next six weeks.
And maybe a little to teach.
The time has come, the time is now (Ash Wednesday Sermon)
Perfection, I quit you
Back in the office now after the Big Event 4.0, a RevGalBlogPals continuing education event, I’m a little overwhelmed by all I learned. I’m trying to absorb, to let things settle into my guts, but it’s hard to do as I run full tilt into Ash Wednesday.
I met women whom I’d only previously “known” through their blogs. I laughed, cried, pondered, and wondered how to bring this good news back, to translate these lessons of hope and grace, how to make change into freedom.
And I’m still jet-lagged.
I had hoped to do another complete month of blogging upon my return, but I missed two days because I was tired and nothing I typed made sense. (This may well still be the case.)
So, I was catching up on my podcasts and I heard this poem on The Writer’s Almanac for 27 February and now I know what to give up for Lent.
Perfection, Perfection
I have had it with perfection.
I have packed my bags,
I am out of here.
Gone.
As certain as rain
will make you wet,
perfection will do you
in.
It droppeth not as dew
upon the summer grass
to give liberty and green
joy.
Perfection straineth out
the quality of mercy,
withers rapture at its
birth.
Before the battle is half begun,
cold probity thinks
it can’t be won, concedes the
war.
I’ve handed in my notice,
given back my keys,
signed my severance check, I
quit.
Hints I could have taken:
Even the perfect chiseled form of
Michelangelo’s radiant David
squints,
the Venus de Milo
has no arms,
the Liberty Bell is
cracked.

